Sonia’s presence in Delhi is costing India dearly

by Francois Gautier
02 Dec 2008
Source: New Indian Express
In 1898, the French writer Emile Zola wrote an open letter to the then French president in the newspaper L’Aurore, titled j’accuse (‘I accuse’), where he accused the French government of anti- Semitism towards Captain Alfred Dreyfus, a Jewish officer unfairly condemned for treason.

Now it is time for the people of India to say openly that which many, including within the Congress, think secretly and may utter in the privacy of their chambers.It is not about Manmohan Singh, it is not even about Shivraj Patil, the fall guy; it is about that one person, the Eminence Grise of India. She who pulls all the strings, She whose shadow looms menacingly over so many, She who holds no portfolio, is just a simple elected MP, like 540 others, but rules like an empress.

Sometimes, one’s very physical presence at the top is enough to move things, to influence the course of events. One word from Her, a glance, a frown, are enough to put the whole heavy, inert, unwilling machinery of India’s bureaucracy and political system in full motion. Sometimes She need not say anything: in the true tradition of Bhakti, Her ministers, Her secretaries, interpret Her silences and rush to cater to Her western and Christian identity.

Nevertheless, she has said and acted enough so that one day she may stand accused on the pages of History for what she must have done to India.

I’accuse Sonia Gandhi as being responsible for the tragedy of Mumbai, having emasculated India’s intelligence agencies by stopping them from investigating terror attacks in the last four years, including the Mumbai train blasts. She has also neutralised the ATS by ordering them at all costs to ferret out ‘Hindu terrorism’, which if it exists, has wrought minuscule damage compared to what Islamic terror has done since 2004.

Did the US send a warning to India that there may be an attack on Mumbai and that the Taj would be one of the targets? Were these ignored because the ATS was too busy chasing Hindu ‘terrorists’ on Sonia’s orders? I accuse Sonia and her government of having made the NSG the laughing stock of the world. How many times did the NSG (who took ten hours to reach Mumbai) claim that it had “sanitised the Taj and that the operation was over” and how many times did a bomb go off immediately after? For the last 20 years, the NSG has guarded VIPs and has become soft. See the comments of Israeli terror specialists, who said the NSG should have first sanitised the immediate surroundings of the places of conflict, kept the bystanders and press (who gave terrorists watching TV in the Taj rooms a perfect report of the security forces’ whereabouts) out of the place, gathered enough information about the position of the terrorists and hostages before taking action, instead of immediately engaging the terrorists, and ensuring the deaths of so many hostages.

I accuse Sonia of having let her Christian and Western background, in four years, divide India on religious and caste lines in a cynical and methodical manner.

I accuse Sonia of weakening India’s spirit of sacrifice and courage, so that 20 terrorists (or less) held at ransom the financial capital of India for more than three days.

I accuse Sonia Gandhi of always pointing the finger at Pakistan, when terrorism in India is now mostly homegrown, even if it takes help, training, refuge and arms from Pakistan; of not warning Indians of the grave dangers of Islamic terror for cynical election purposes.

I accuse Sonia of being an enemy of the Hindus, who always gave refuge to persecuted minorities, and who are the only people in the world to accept that God may manifest under different names, in different epochs, using different scriptures.

I accuse Sonia Gandhi of taking advantage of India’s respect for women, its undue fascination with the Gandhi name, and its stupid mania for White Skin.

I’accuse Sonia of exploiting the Indian Press’ obsession with her. She hardly ever gave interview in 20 years, except scripted ones to NDTV, yet the Press always protects her, never blames her and keeps silent over her covert role.

I’accuse Sonia and her government of trying to make heroes of subservient and inefficient men to hide the humiliation of Mumbai 26/11. Before going to his death, Hemant Karkare, the ATS chief, was shown on television clumsily handling his helmet, as someone who uses it very rarely. Why did he die of bullet wounds in the chest when he was wearing a bullet-proof vest? Either Indian vests are inferior quality or he was not wearing one.

How did the terrorists who killed him and his fellow officer escape in the same vehicle used by the ATS chief ? Why did he and his officers go into Cama Hospital without ascertaining where the terrorists were? We honour his death, but these facts say a lot about the ATS’ battle-readiness.

Will someone in the Congress, someone who feels more Indian than faithful to Sonia, stand up and speak the truth? Who said, “Go after Hindu terrorists”? Who insisted on putting pressure on BJP governments in Karnataka or Orissa for so-called persecution of Christians, when Christians have always practised their faith in total freedom here, while their missionaries are converting hundreds of thousands of innocent tribals and Dalits with the billions of dollars given by gullible westerners? Who said, “Go soft on Islamic terrorism”? Who wants to do away with India’s nuclear deterrence in the face of Pakistani and Chinese nuclear threats, by pushing at all costs the one sided Indo-US nuclear deal, which makes no secret of its intention to denuclearise India militarily? I am sure Sonia Gandhi has good qualities: she probably was a good wife to Rajiv, a good daughter in law to Indira and by all accounts, she is a good mother to her children. One also hears first-hand reports about her concern for smaller people, her dignity in the suffering that befell her when her husband was blown to pieces, and her courtesy with visitors.

Nevertheless, she is a danger to India.

Her very presence, both physical and occult, open the doors to forces inimical to India. Even Indian Christians should understand that she is not a gift to them: her presence at the top has emboldened fanatics like John Dayal or Valson Thampu, who practise an orthodox Christianity prevalent in the West in the early 20th century, but no longer, to radicalise their flock. Indian Christians should recognise that they have a much better deal here than Christians or Hindus have in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Indonesia or Saudi Arabia.

Under Sonia’s rule, Indian Muslims, too, have been used as electoral pawns. They have been encouraged to shun the Sufi streak, a blend of the best of Islam and Vedanta, for a hard-line Sunni brand imported from Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Afghanistan.

For the good of India, her civilisation, her immense spirituality and culture, Sonia Gandhi has to go and a government that thinks Indian, breathes nationalism and will protect its citizens must be voted to power.


20 responses to “Sonia’s presence in Delhi is costing India dearly

  1. Its the truth and what Francois Gautier has written is 100% correct. If Sonia Gandhi gets out of politics it would be a greatest benefit to this nation. Nation has to be led by the one who is true national to the core and understands its pulse. Indian pulse is spirituality and that can be understood and felt only by an Indian blood because it has that inherent character which Sonia or her children cant feel in this life. Really an eye opener. Truth has to be accepted no one can deny truth even society fails to accept it that society will perish. Truth of the hour is Sonia’s Presence is harming this nation too much.

  2. Hi Francois,
    I have been regularly reading your articles in Indian Express and has been wondering who this guy is. I await your article every time. Your wise and broad outlook of Indian culture and a bold approach has always amazed. Wish our Indian journalists learn few lessons from you. Specially media like NDTV, THE HINDU and other few who in the name of democracy, equality and secularism have cried foul over hindu terrorism when Islamic terror running riot and Christian conversions running amok. Either they refuse to realize the reality or acting at the behest of pseudo-secularists one can’t say.
    Both NDTV and THE HINDU have been very biased when commenting about islamic terrorism. You correctly pointed about the inside picture of Sonia’s imperial rule and this shameless Indian politika. Just wish media wakes up to reality and start portraying the truth and revive the Indian nationalism so that the public get aroused and identify the pseudos.
    Keep up the good work and write more articles in Indian Express.

  3. Dear Mr. Gautier, I think it is Francois Gautiers, L K Advanis, Naresndra Modis and their likes whose presence in India that is costing us dearly.

    In this disguise of an article, Mr Gautier, like most other Hindu terror perpetrators, spews venom and injects hatred into the minds.

    Most Hindus I meet in India — be it in cities like Bombay or Delhi, or in the remotest of the villages in India — just hate Muslims. They are taught Muslims are our enimies, and they are here to kill us. This hatred holds against Christians also to a certain extent.

    I do not see this hatred reciprocated in Muslims. Most Muslims do not hate Hindus, and they hate, and are afraid of, the so called “Islamic terrorists” as much as the Hindus do (if not more).

    Which is why I think this statement is a big lie and an attempt to mislead people. You say,

    “I accuse Sonia Gandhi as being responsible for the tragedy of Mumbai, having emasculated India’s intelligence agencies by stopping them from investigating terror attacks in the last four years, including the Mumbai train blasts. She has also neutralised the ATS by ordering them at all costs to ferret out “Hindu terrorism”, which if it exists, has wrought minuscule damage compared to what Islamic terror has done since 2004.”

    Terror “Investigations” in India have mostly been about picking up all Muslims in the area and making some of them admit doing crimes. In case of Pragya Singh we got to hear stories of Police torture for the first time in mainstream media, and they claimed they confessed under fear. Good that it came out at least in such a twist to the story. Confession under police custody happens most of the times under fear, and the main clause in POTA is that these confessions (in Police custody) can be taken as evidence.

    It was the Congress and UPA who managed a drama of an encounter at Batla house to save the face of Shivraj Patil after the Delhi blasts. My friends who teach at Jamia have been telling stories of how the Police have been trying to frame the Muslim students. I don’t know what “Orders” of Sonia this guy is talking about.

    Also, I think the hatred brand of terrorism (yes, Hindu terrorism, without quotes) has wrought much more damage to India’s integrity than what is caused by the terrorist attacks.

    I do not know why this guy has used a timeline that starts from 2004 — it is to erase Gujarat cleansing of Muslims that was a good example of how this hate machine can work when ignited?


    Related stuff from my blog posts:
    Where does Aamir Lead Us
    Costume Designers of Delhi Police
    Intolerance and Indigestion

  4. Is this like the 10 commandments of accusation? Okay, Sonia is controlling Indian govt. So what’s your point?

  5. Mr Fancois Gautier is right on dot every time he writes an artcle. For example Mr Vilasrao Desmukh thanks Sonia for his twice CMship of
    Maharashtra. He forgets elementary constitutional principle that the CM or PM
    is elected by the legislature party or the
    parliamentary party. Instead it is the two
    moghuls Sonia and Pawar deciding it. Sonia
    damaged India beyond recognition a process started by Nehru and Indira. In the last 4 years India has degraded into a Banana republic.

  6. This is very good story, comments are very intelligent.

    India have 1.13 billion population. Here are some facts to consider and act.

    1. India is been virtually ruled by Sonia Gandhi (Italian Born).
    2. Nehru/Gandhi family have been ruling India like King & are treated like King.
    3. All Muslims in Pakistan or India are converted Muslims (brothers and Sisters of Hindu). It have been only 52 years before it was called Pakistan. It is part of Hindustan since stongage.
    4. Everyone in India/Hindustan are Hindus (Hindu Religion is Sanātana Dharma [Sanskrit Meaning “the eternal law”]) no matter if your Vaisnava, Shikh, Jain, Christian or Muslim. We have 68 thousand good under this Dharms.

    Lets be United Hindustan…


  7. more truth in the article than one can believe & comprehend unless s/he is mature enough to feel the truth rather than understand the meening of the sentences

  8. This guy Mr. Francois Gautier is juz trying to create hatred among we Indians on the basis of Religion or politics.Are not Muslims Indians?Does it matter if Sonia rules the country or Advani?Did BJP do anything extraordinary that he’s writing such an article against her?Was there not terrorist attacks in Kashmir during BJP’s Reign?More people were killed in Gujarat riots than any terrosrist attacks.This was in a state ruled BJP. Instead of Initiating actions against these RIOTING TERRORISTS, BJP leaders claims it to be just a reaction to Godhra Attacks.People caught red handed in the sting operation of Tahelka for leaking of vital information belonged to which party?Why did BJP defend such them and the likes of Sadhvi Pragya?I dont dont have bias against any particula political party or Religion. I would rather vote for a person in my Area who is LESS CORRUPT rather deciding on the basis of BJP and congress.I would request Mr. Francois Gautier to stop posting such articles of hatred.He must realize Hindus, Muslims, Christians or Sikhs; Congress or BJP, We all are Indians and we must be proud to be Indians.

  9. Hi Francois,
    Amazed to go through your article. Felt like you have given words to my views and feelings. Of course Your article has added much to my knowledge about Sonia. I agree and support your view.
    Keep it up.

  10. The greatest damage that the British & other foreign invaders have done is to the Indian mind rather than the Indian land.They have succeeded in implanting the idea that somehow their Brown skin is inferior to the White.And so in order to get the approval of the White Western world they constantly indulge in self-ricrimination & Hindu bashing.We forget that ours is a much older & richer civilization & the most tolerant in the world.We dont need to demean ourselves to get the approval of the white world.Mr. Gautier speaks not(thankfully)as a “Benevolent Westerner”but as an individual, a human being who has the courage to think independently & express his frustration at Indians who are yet to wake up to their self-worth.Every Indian irrespective of religion, caste & creed needs to understand that the world will respect us for our freedom of thought rather than our pseudo-secularism which encourages reverse discrimination against the Hindu community simply because it is in majority & hence an imagined threat to all other minorities.Throwing out one Sonia Gandhi is not the solution as she can easily be replaced by someone else who may not be white of skin but will think like the Whites.The greatest need of the hour is independent & radical thinking & decisive action for the good of the nation.

  11. Its was a nice article to read , whether to believe it or not is in individuals hand. But we as Indians should be able to judge who is the right person to rule our Country rather than trying to point the fingers on others.

    1st mistake we by and large do is we dnt vote and we start blameing and commenting on Politicians.

    Dear Indian friends, this election we should all go out and vote and elect a right person for our place and Country.

    Jai Hind.

  12. It is like we fought the British so we could be ruled by Italy. You pulled the words right out of my mouth!

  13. Monsieur Gautier

    J´ accuse you of being another fundamentalist.
    Do not bring religion and specifically , Christianity into almost every article you write. You only serve the purpose of other fundamentalists that India is swarming in. And India does not need a foreigner like you to add to its woes.
    Ever thought of presenting constructive views on what India must do at the operational level to tackle it zillion challenges.? Getting rid of Sonia is the least (and perhaps the most insignificant) of them.

    Peace , tolerance and goodwill to you this Christmas

    Hubert Rau

  14. I fully endorse what Francois has written. It is high time these congress Men speak out for themselves and get up and serve their own countrymen as one and not depend upon a woman for orders and instructions.

    In Love and good faith.
    Renu Bose

  15. Oneday Sonia will suffre for her sins together with all those who support her. She will take birth in hellish worlds for he sins towards India. God is watching her!

  16. Pingback: Time for Sonia to quit politics, if not country! – B.R. Haran « Bharata Bharati

  17. Very true. All her good qualities have eaten up by the power poison. Also I believe all Gandhi’s are controlled by powerful congress mafia from behind & those people will not let these people go anywhere. Even if Sonia Gandhi wants to go back to Italy, they wont allow her to go. The family is trapped here in my opinion.

  18. Well said, You are hit the bulls eye. This drama behind the screen is not known to many od Indian so media is fed to feed news favouring family. This family ruined india for past 65 years. the Blind man Nehru vision and blunders after blunders( still India ignorant and family has projected him as Greatest hero, Pity it is techinc Indians media Inteletual has fallen to Dynastic dictatorship) Every decator projected as greated savoiur of people and ills will be covered. Will the cubboard w be cleared Once this dynasty felled. Pity India had chance twice but succumbed to CON in 1977 and 1998 Vajpeyi Govt was just sleepng with enemy and did more than willing servat of Family. Pity is that Large number of Indians/Hindus are ignorant and still part of plot without knowing( some commets here are best example) . Saddest part is the Indias are acting like People in George orwell “Shooting an Elephant” story, they dont know they are destroying their own wealth but enjoying killing if Elephant(/Wealth/India/ History/Culture…..) by foreighner and his tool.

  19. Body organs needed urgently at Apollo Hospital my name is Dr Max Newton ,we offer $850,000 USD contact me via whatsapp number: +917676505791.

  20. JGD. Francois Gautier; possibly, it is the design of DESTINY that you (just like Baba Ramdev) are standing up for the Hindus in these times. Keep up your good work. You could be more vocal (and visible) about your opinions and create greater impact in the Decision Making process.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s