As Sonia Gandhi has filed her nomination for the 2014 elections, from Rae Barely, which will probably reelect her, I thought it would be appropriate to republish this article of mine. ..

Like Sonia Gandhi, I am a Westerner and a brought-up catholic. My father, a very good man, was a staunch Christian; my uncle, whom I doted upon, was the vicar of the Montmartre Church, one of the most picturesque landmarks of Paris. Like Sonia Gandhi, I have lived in India for more than 40 years, and I have had the good fortune to be married to an Indian.
But the comparison stops there. I did land in India with a certain amount of prejudices, clichés and false ideas, that most Westerners pick-up here and there (Tintin, Kipling, the City of Joy, Slumdog Millionaire, today) and I did think in the enthusiasm of my youth to become a missionary to bring back Indian ‘pagans’ to the ‘true God’. But the moment I stepped in India I felt that not only I had nothing much that I could give to India, but rather, that it was India which was bestowing me.

In fact, in 40 years, India has given me so much, professionally, spiritually, sentimentally. Most Westerners, who come here, still think they are here to ‘give’ something to a country, which, unconsciously of course, they think is lesser than theirs. It was true of the British, it was true of Mother Teresa, it is true of Mrs Sonia Gandhi.

It is a fact that Sonia brought discipline, order and cohesion into the Congress party. But the amount of power, that she, a non-Indian, a simple elected MP, like hundreds of others, possesses, should frighten her: a word, nay a glance of her is sufficient to trigger action by her entourage, using any means. Thus, the instruments of power have never been so perverted in India. The CBI blatantly and shamelessly quashed all injunctions against Quattrochi and even allowed him to get away with billions of rupees which he had stolen from India. Yet, without batting an eyelid, and with the Indian Media turning a blind eye, it went ruthlessly after Narendra Modi, the Chief Minister of the most efficiently run state, the most corruption free, where there is electricity 24 hours, when half of India is in darkness, where there is unlimited water supply whereas a drought-like situation is evolving in many states. Now that Mr Modi, is the BJP’s Prime ministerial candidate, he has of course acquired some shine in the Indian Media, though the western Media continues to bash him ruthlessly and untruthfully, as recently Gardiner Harris did in the New York Times.

Are Indians aware that their country has been for the last few years in a state of semi-autocracy, where every important decision comes to a single individual, residing in her fortress of Janpath, surrounded by dozens of security men, an empress of India. Are they aware that she controls tens of billions of rupees of the taxpayer’s money, which she uses to keep her party in power? Do they know that the huge amounts of the scams, whether the 2G, the CWG, or the Adarsh one, did not go into politicians pockets (only a fraction), but to the coffers of the Congress for these general elections, and more than anything to please Sonia, who is trying to install her son on the throne of India? The Congress, with Sonia’s overt or silent consent, has paid during two tenures hundreds thousands of crores of rupees to buy MP’s to topple non-Congress governments. Her governors shamelessly hijacked democracy by twisting the laws. Thank God, the Judiciary here still holds some independence!

Nobody seems to notice what happened under the reign of Sonia Gandhi. That many leftist intellectuals, such as Teesta Seltawad, or Manu Joseph, were allowed to preach secession in India, whereas on the other hand the Congress Government has been going after the army, the last body in India to uphold the time ancient values of the Kshatriya –courage, honour, devotion to the Motherland, they who alone today practice true secularism, never differentiating between a Muslim or Hindu soldier, and who, for a pittance, give daily their lives to their country. First it was the attempt of a caste census, a divide and rule ploy if there is one; then there are the many signs that the Government was thinking about thinning down the presence of the Indian army in the Kashmir Valley, which will suit Pakistan perfectly.

One hears from persons who know her well, of Sonia’s’ qualities of honesty, courtesy, or personal care. But would be impossible, in France for example, to have a non-Christian, say an Hindu for instance, who is a non-elected president or PM, to be the absolute ruler of the country behind the scenes, superseding even the PM. There are many capable people in the Congress. Why can’t a billion Indians find one of their own, who will understand the complexity and subtlety of India, to govern themselves? Not only that, but her very presence at the top has unleashed forces, visible and invisible that are detrimental to the country. There is nothing wrong in espousing the best of the values of the West – democracy, technological perfection, higher standards of living – but many of the institutions are crumbling in the West: two out of three marriages end in divorce, kids shoot each other, parents are not cared for in their old age, depression is rampant and westerners are actually looking for answers elsewhere, in India notably.

One does not understand this craze at the moment to westernize India at all costs, while discarding its ancient values. Mrs Gandhi should have remembered while in power that there still are 850 million Hindus in India, 1,2 billion worldwide and that whatever good inputs were brought by different invasions, it is the ancient values of the spirituality behind Hinduism, which have made India so special and which gives her today her unique qualities, making an Indian Christian different from an American Christian, or an Indian Muslim different from a Saudi one.

Every opinion poll says the Congress will suffer debacle in these elections, but if you talk to many of the simple countryside people, whether in UP or Tamil Nadu, they say that they are going to vote for Congress ‘because my husband tells me’, or because ‘Rahul is related to the Mahatma Gandhi’…
The tragedy of India is that it was colonized for too long. And unlike China, it always looks to the West for a solution to its problems. Sonia Gandhi, whatever her qualities, is just an incarnation of that hangover, an Empress of India in new clothes.

Francois Gautier

 The author is editor in chief of the Paris based La Nouvelle Revue de l’Inde ( and the author of many books, amongst them The Guru of Joy (Hay House, 125.000 copies in seven countries)

20 responses to “THE EMPRESS OF INDIA (2)

  1. Superb…..Francois I believe very few Indian can write what you have written here….

  2. brilliant! Kudos to you!

  3. H L Parthasarathy

    Only people like you who are real well wishers of Bharatwasis can have the courage to write an article like this.

  4. Wow… You captured the true feelings of Indians who feel the same but hardly can write on it… Hats Off

  5. Wow!

  6. Since when was Rahul related to Mahatma Gandhi ? o.O

  7. Dabangg hindu

    I don’t agree with last para as CNNIBN showed a live program by sagarikaghose in a chaupal at NOIDA farsabad where every people of dalit says they will vote for MODI this time

  8. Ashok Sharma

    God bless you for awreness and pride frugal jaichands allowing widow to vest power?

  9. arunakrishnan

    Well written blog. The sycophancy in the Congress party is beyond common understanding. Agree with you when you say… “There are many capable people in the Congress. Why can’t a billion Indians find one of their own, who will understand the complexity and subtlety of India, to govern themselves? “….It is indeed time we shook off colonialism once & for all.

  10. Gaurav M.Rau

    Jai Gurudev, Francois. You hit the nail on the head; wonderful prose with meanings inbetween the lines.

  11. Excellent article… Alas Congress will always enjoy a soft-corner amongst Indian voters – may it be for the deaths of Indira, Rajiv or may it be for their unauthentic Last Name of the Congress controlling family.

  12. More power to you:-)

  13. Satish Khurana

    Sir! The problem is that we know everything but like this. We have slave mentality and we deserve to be slaves. Not many of us are independent thinkers. Most “intellectuals” are just well read individuals, tell me what can they teach common man? Even the fight of independence was inspired by foreign stories. I get surprised that they needed those stories to revolt against unfair rulers? And now, the same situation is facing us and what are we fed on? Absolutely shamelessly biased media and fake intellectuals, who, if successful in guiding masses will bring India down to dust in no time. The worst thing that this govt. and previous Cong governments is that they destroyed independent institutions if there were any. But the good thing is that they still exist in some form. So, the hope is there as in democracy we get what we deserve as masses. The day we will deserve good govt., we will get one.

  14. mohini suri

    I am glad that this has come from you as Indian media is bogged down in trivialities which impact immediate elections.It is high time they rise above such mundane propaganda & expose true picture in peripheral areas so that rural masses understand the real Sonia & Congress

  15. Dear Friends,
    The author has indeed again tried to awaken this nation against a slavery mindset that we have inherited from our immediate past. Besides Sonia Gandhi, some high ranking and well placed dignitaries have not got over their love for Pakistan blindfold, notwithstanding the fact that Pakistan has vowed to destroy India by breaking it into ten parts using India’s internal dissensions by provoking fissures in its demography. The solution has to be to arouse PRIDE in INDIA in every citizen, irrespective of his religion, caste, creed, language or region. This needs start at the school, where we need to inculcate the true history of India, pride in ts cultural heritage without doing down one or the other, but not shying away from showing foreign invaders and looters and sword wielding tyrants in the light they should be shown in
    We (self and wife) were in a museum in Paris when a stranger, later identified as former US Military Attache in India, asked us a silly question or that is what I thought of it initially,he asked ” Are You from India? On our positive response, he said, “Have you seen India?” And it took me a little time to realise what he was trying to convey. That is the state of most of us Indians, and particularly the so called intellectuals
    I cant even say ‘Enjoy the article’ because one feels depressed after reading it that even this truth and sane advice has to be told to us by a foreigner, a well wisher of India

  16. Very poignant message. But will the general public hear it? They have no idea that Sonia Gandhi’s name has no relation to Mahatma Gandhi. Indira Gandhi’s husband was of Parsi lineage and was a ‘Khan”. It was Mahatma Gandhi who christened him ‘Gandhi’ and elevated him into the elite circle. And the name gathered some charismatic mist.

  17. Why blame Mrs. Gandhi? The real traitor culprits are members of her party and her sycophants who have no pride in their own history, culture, and society. Perhaps, as one of your readers says, only people with ‘slave mentality’ survived and flourished in the 400+ years of Mogul+British rule; these folks now constitute the elite class who continue to see their survival in rejection of their own Indian-ness.

  18. Hats off…..this article appear in the front-line media, in all regional languages too…I wished !!

  19. Body organs needed urgently at Apollo Hospital my name is Dr Max Newton ,we offer $850,000 USD contact me via whatsapp number: +917676505791.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s