As the sting operation by investigative website Cobrapost on the 1992 Babri Mosque demolition at Ayodhya, is released, I thought I could share this article on Ayodhya which I wrote in 1992 for the Mumbai newspaper Blitz


 How many of those who have lambasted so many times the “Hindu fundamentalists” and lamented the destruction of the Babri Masjid mosque as the “death of secularism in India”, have been to Ayodhya? (not Faizabad, mind you, which is Ayodhya’s twin Muslim city). When one arrived in Ayodhya before the destruction of the mosque, one was struck by the fact that it was a Hindu town “par excellence”. More than Benares even, it is dotted everywhere with innumerable temples; it has all these old Hindus houses and this lovely river with its ghats which runs through the lower town. And then, forlorn on the top, there was this lone mosque with its two ugly domes, which looked so out of place and unused, that any one with a right sense -and that includes the Muslims- should see that it was not worth making an issue of. The destruction of the Babri Masjid still evokes such fiery reactions, that the importance of Ayodhya has been totally overlooked: Ayodhya is a symbol, through which two India’s are facing each other. And the outcome of their confrontation will shape the future of this country for generations to come.

 The first India wants to be secular and unite together through an egalitarian, democratic spirit all the minorities, ethnic groups, religions and people of the country. But the question is: what would be the binding element of this kind of India? Secularism, says the first side. But secularism has a different meaning for each one. For the British, it was a convenient way to divide and rule, by treating each Indian community on par, although some were in minority and others in majority, thereby planting the seeds of separatisms. For the Congress Party, it has always meant giving in to the Muslims’ demands, because its leaders never could really make out if the allegiance of Indian Muslims first want to India and then to Islam – or vice-versa. And for India’s intelligentsia, its writers, journalists, top bureaucrats, the majority of whom are Hindus, it means, apart from belittling its own religion and brothers, an India which would be a faithful copy of the West: liberal, modern, atheist, industrialized, intellectual and western-oriented.

 Moreover, what makes India unique? Certainly not its small elite which apes the West; there are millions of these western clones in the developing world who wear a tie, read the New York Times and swear by liberalism and secularism to save their countries from doom. Nor its modern youth, whom you meet in Delhi’s swank parties, who are full of the MTV culture, wear the latest Klein jeans and Lacoste T Shirts, and who in general are useless, fat, rich parasites, in a country which has so many talented youngsters who live in poverty. Not even its political, bureaucratic and judicial system; it’s a copy of the British set up, which is not fully adapted to India’s unique character and conditions. What then?

 The second India which is confronting the other through the Ayodhya issue is, of course, the India of the Hindus. When Imam Bhukari states that “we (the Mughals) gave everything to this country, its culture, its manners, its arts, and the Hindus by destroying the Babri Masjid showed how little gratitude they have”, apart from making a pompous declaration, he proclaims exactly the opposite of the reality. Because the truth is that not only Hinduism is what makes India unique, so different from all the other nations of the world, but it is the single most important influence in Indian history. In the words of Sri Aurobindo, India’s Great Sage and Modern Age Avatar: “The inner principle of Hinduism, the most tolerant and receptive of all religious systems, is not sharply exclusive like the religious spirit of Christianity or Islam…it is the fulfillment of the highest tendencies of human civilisation and it will include in its sweep the most vital impulses of modern life..”

 And indeed, if you look at India today, you find that Hinduism has permeated, influenced, shaped, every part of this country, every religion, every culture. Be it the Christians who are like no other Catholics of the world, or Indian Muslims, who whatever they may say, are utterly different from their brothers in Saudi Arabia. But Hinduism is too narrow a word, it’s a corruption of the original word “Indu”, for true Hinduism is Dharma, India’s infinite and eternal spiritual knowledge, which took shape into so many varied expressions throughout the ages, be it the Vedantas, Buddhism, or the Arya Samaj and which is today still very much alive in India, particularly in its rural masses, which after all constitute 80% of its population. And the words of the great Sage still echo in our ears: “Each nation is a shakti or power of the evolving spirit in humanity and lives by the principle it embodies. India is the Bharata Shakti, the living energy of a great spiritual conception- and fidelity to it is the very principle of her existence…But we must have a firm faith that India must rise and be great and that everything that happened, every difficulty, every reverse must help and further the end…”

 What one has to grasp is that the issue of Ayodhya only makes sense when the immense harm the Muslims did to India is not negated, as indeed it has been and still is today in the official History books in the West – and sadly in India also. The Muslim jehad against Hindus, alas, continues even today, whether in Kashmir, where the last Hindus were made to flee in terror, or in Bangladesh and Pakistan, where the crowds still regularly go on rampage against Hindus and their temples (as told by a Bangladeshi Muslim herself, Talisma Nasreen). It is in this light, that it becomes extraordinary for an impartial observer to see today that when for once, the Hindus wanted to displace, not even to destroy, ONE mosque and rebuild the “temple”, which they believe was built in this particular place, for one of their most cherished Gods, the one which is loved universally by all, men, women, children, THEY were treated as rabid fundamentalists. The great Mughals must be laughing all the way down their graves! What a reversal of situation! What a turnabout of history! And when the mosque was destroyed, it evoked such fiery reactions, such pompous, overblown, sanctimonious, holier-than-thou, atrocious, ridiculous, sly and totally undeserved outrage, both within India and in the Western world (who should be the last one to give lessons to India), that the importance of Ayodhya as a symbol has been totally overlooked.

 The obvious trap is to think that the demolition of the mosque in Ayodhya is something to gloat about and that it is the duty of all good Hindus to see that other important mosques at Mathura, Vanarasi, or elsewhere, be also razed to the ground; or that all cities with a Muslim name be renamed with a Hindu one. This is not true Hinduism, which has always shown its tolerance and accepted in its fold other creeds and faiths. Indeed a true “Indu” India will be secular in the correct sense of the term: it will give freedom to each religion, each culture, so that it develops itself in the bosom of a Greater India, of which dharma, true spirituality, will be the cementing factor.

Nevertheless, the destruction of the Babri Masjid, however unfortunate, has made its point: the occult Mughal hold over Hindu India has been broken and centuries of Hindu submission erased. Hindus have proved that they too can fight.


 * The author, is the correspondent in South Asia of Le Figaro, France’s largest circulation newspaper.


28 responses to “

  1. Akshay Malhotra

    The problem is Hindus have forgotten their own forefathers sacrifices and their own holocaust which is the biggest in the world.

    Today’s mentality of Hindus is mostly slave mentality due to education of Britishers !!

  2. why some of English educated Indians are so cut off from their route and blindly ape west?
    why such convergence of agenda of main stream english media and left intellectual hogging panel discussion and pedaling their agenda and belittling our heritage,past culture and religion?

  3. Islam is not a religion of peace


    Honestly, you are more Indian in spirit than large number of Indians themselves. Heartfelt thank you for everything you have done.

    I wish that you get everything you hoped for in life, and more. May God continue to shower his blessing in your life. I really hope I get to meet you one day. Please let me know if I can be of any help to you.

    If you were hurt by anyone while you were / are in India, I apologize on behalf of all of them.

  4. Great article ! I hope Francois writes specifically about about the media is working full time against hindus. The hindu is a newspaper that stands out as the main villain in south. Please write about the various idiots like Vidya Subramanian, Ramachandra Guha, Harish Khare, Smitha etc who blabber nonsense against hindus all the time.

  5. Ashok Sharma

    So nice of you bless you dr ak

  6. Col R C Verma

    An excellent article which should open the narrow mind with which so many of our own countrymen view Hinduism.Ours is a great Nation with such a wonderful and robust Religion and it should be our endeavour to keep it that way.

  7. Hi there, after reading this amazing post i am as well happy to share my knowledge here with colleagues.

  8. I have read so many articles or reviews about the blogger lovers
    however this post is genuinely a fastidious piece of
    writing, keep it up.

  9. fantastic issues altogether, you just gained a logo new reader.
    What would you recommend in regards to your put
    up that you made some days in the past? Any certain?

  10. Piuttosto bella postale. Ho semplicemente appena imbattuto il tuo blog weblog e volevo menzionare che ho realmente goduto navigazione intorno weblog messaggi.
    In ogni caso ti essere registrarmi sul Feed e spero
    si scrive nuovo molto presto!

  11. Ahoj, rád čtu přes váš Článek příspěvek.

    I jako napsat malou poznámku, aby ho podpořili.

  12. Ich mag, was euch sind in der Regel bis zu. Diese Art
    der Arbeit und kluge Berichterstattung! Halten Sie sich die hervorragende wunderbar funktioniert Jungs enthalten euch zu meine persönliche.
    hier. Ich werde Rückkehr Blog für mehr bald.
    und mit
    Spot on mit dieser Zuschreibung, Ich glauben, dass diese Website diese Seite
    Bedürfnisse viel mehr Aufmerksamkeit. Wahrscheinlich werde ich wieder zurück
    sein Rückkehr zu lesen mehr zu sehen, danke für die info
    Website ‘s Post regelmäßig aktualisiert werden . Es enthält enthält good Datum.
    für Blog, ich Ihnen von
    Hallo Ich bin so dankbar, aufgeregt Website, während
    ich die Erforschung Suche über Digg Askjeeve für Blog, ich Ihnen von
    Ausstehende allerdings Allerdings wurde ich gefragt, wollen wissen, wenn Sie einen litte mehr
    zu diesem Thema zu schreiben Thema ? Ich wäre sehr dankbar, dankbar,
    wenn Sie ein wenig Brombeeren erarbeiten weitere Top.

  13. Hallo Ich habe einfach wollen geben Ihnen einen Daumen hoch für die ausgezeichbnete Informationen Sie haben
    Gute Informationen. Glück für mich fand ich Ihre Website
    zufällig (stumbleupon). Ich habe es vorgemerkt als Favorit gespeichert für später auf!
    und mit
    Groß Blog hier! Auch Ihre Website website Lasten bis fast sehr schnell!
    Welche host verwenden Sie? Kann ich Ihren Affiliate-Link
    zu Ihrer Gast? Ich wünschte, mein als schnell wie deine lol Website ‘s Post regelmäßig aktualisiert werden
    Hallo zusammen, ständig i verwendet, um zu überprüfen, website Beiträge hier Anfang am Morgen, da Liebe bis Gewinn von Wissen und vieles mehr.
    für Blog, ich Ihnen von Fehler gefunden etwas anderes, Unabhängig Ich bin jetzt hier und möchte nur sagen, vielen Dank
    prost wunderbare unterhaltsam Blogs (ich liebe
    auch das Thema / Design), ich habe keine Zeit,
    um zu lesen, durch Blick über alles auf die Minute Moment, aber ich habe Buch-Kennzeichnung Lesezeichen und es auch aufgenommen in Ihre RSS-Feeds hinzugefügt, so, wenn ich Zeit
    habe werde ich zurück sein, las sehr mehr, Bitte
    halten Sie die genial b. für Blog, ich Ihnen von
    Dies ist mein erstes Mal zahlen einen kurzen Besuch bei hier, und ich bin wirklich wirklich pleassant zu lesen all ein einzigen Ort.

  14. For tes of you which an be looking for a gret binary choices broker you sould definitely take a look at
    our binary coices rokers part the place we record solely the very best brokers together wth the latest and exclusiv promotions.
    That it is one and only one form of investing where one can start trading with a deposit instantly and that returns can start pouring in instantly which can also be withdrawn if so be
    the need. Say we try a different tack and re-invest our profit with our initial

  15. Տublime poste : continue de cette manière

  16. Il me tardе de lire le prochain post

  17. Eսhhh êtes vous sûr de ce que voսs nous affirmwz ??

  18. Je me рermets d’écrirece com uniquement pouг congratuler son auteur

  19. Ѵous faîtes toujours des posfs attraϲtifs

  20. All your emotions’laughter, sorrow, cheerfulness and Wholesale Snapback Hatsworry’are expressed
    on your face. Snapback hats are merging with a lot of other developments from the 90s these kinds of as black hairstyles and other amazing
    retro variations like classic jerseys worn by
    many NBA groups that consist of but are not minimal to the Cleveland Cavaliers.
    Custom surfboards can be ordered online and in store and are
    all manufactured in Newquay UK.

  21. Both, animal and plant foods can outstanding sources of protein. Excess Drug or Alcohol Use ‘ You may have
    heard before that illicit drug use works as a negative factor if you want to get pregnant.

    Changes in your body during pregnancy will occur during the different trimesters.

  22. This type of dumpster are used in building, house renovation, yard
    clear up, business clear ups, and industrial clean ups.

  23. Je poste сe commentaire simplement pour remercier l’auteur

  24. Une fois de plus սn poste sincèrement plaisant

  25. Magnificent web site. Lots of helpful information here. I am
    sending it to several buddies ans additionally sharing in delicious.
    And obviously, thanks to your sweat!

  26. I have wondered the same on this topic, junk to most but absolutely gold to others.
    I will expand on this topic soon. stay safe my friend.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s