FOREIGNERS AND INDIA

India says it needs foreign investment and that it welcomes foreigners on its land. But before even arriving in India, the hapless foreigner will have to queue for hours at Indian consulates to get a paltry three month visa – even if he has been visiting India for the last 30 years. The first impressions of a western businessman landing in India might very well have a bearing on whether he is going at all to invest here. However, he has again to queue for at least an hour at Immigration and deal with surly officers; and the moment he comes out of the airport, he is assailed by touts and his prepaid taxi is in such a bad condition, that he shudders at every corner ! Henceforth, at each step, he will be made to feel that rather than being welcomed, he is a cow to be milked ! Five Star hotels, for instance, will charge him exorbitant prices: from 400 $ a night (Imperial / Delhi), to (500 $ (Oberoi / Bombay). Compare this to the 150 $ a night charged by the Shangri-La in Singapore, a fabulous hotel, which boasts many more facilities than all the Oberoi and Taj of India, or the 120 $ of the Colombo Hilton. Is he decides to go to Hampi or Mahabalipuram, he will also be made to cough-up 40% more than Indians, to have a glimpse at the Taj Mahal in Agra (and only 50 Rs ) ! Can you think of a more flagrant discrimination ? No wonder China gets 10 more time visitors !

 

By not welcoming foreigners as honoured guests, an old Hindu tradition, the Indian Government seems to forget that foreigners have made significant contributions to India. One immediately thinks of Sister Nivedita, Vivekandanda’s disciple, who not only gave her life for the upliftment of women in India, but also played an active role in India’s early independence movement. Today, scholars like American David Frawley , keep reminding Indians about the greatness, past and present, of their country and how India still has an important role to play in the world. Of course, there are also the “misguided” – but good-willing foreigners. Max Mueller was one of them: he is the first westerner, after William Jones, to have discovered the genius of Sanskrit. Unfortunately, Mueller is also responsible for many of the biases of today’s Indian history, such as the postdating of the Vedas, or the ridiculous theorem of an Aryan invasion of India, which all recent archaeological and linguistic discoveries disavow. Mrit, murli manohar joshi, @other Teresa could also be labelled in this category: she worked tirelessly for India’s poor, but never cared to counterbalance the very negative image of India she was incarnating, by a more positive one.

 

Finally, you have the ignorant and arrogant foreigners. English colonisers must have been the first of them : not only did they wilfully leave behind them a mess, which triggered Partition, but they also bred many generations of “Macaulay’s children”, who today look at their own culture as the British once looked at India. Sonia Gandhi may be another of these “conceited” foreigners: all her life she has been cloistered in Delhi, either because she led the life of an upper class Indian before her husband became PM, or because she is supposed to be under security threat. She has thus no idea about the genius of India, which lies in its countryside – and not in arrogant and superficial Delhi. Yet she chose to head India’s oldest party… and has led it to its downfall, its lowest electoral tally ever ! Is President Obama, or French President Hollande, who always put pressure on India to negotiate Kashmir without knowing anything about the complexities of the situation and India’s rightful preoccupations?

 

Much of Japanese ancient culture – Zen Buddhism, its martial arts, Bonsai – was saved from total extinction by the foreigners’ (read US) interest in them. Will the same thing happen to India ? Today, there is a massive outcry from the Indian intelligentsia, every time this government tries to switch from a westernised and Marxist India to a more Indianised one, a culture much-much older than any Western ideology. This is exactly what Smriti Irani might try to do, thereby earning the ire and the scorn of the “secular” Press. They will mock her, like they ridiculed Murli Manohar Joshi twenty years ago, when he tried to introduce the singing of Vande Mataram in schools! Does it need then a westerner to tell India that it boasts one of the greatest and oldest Books of Wisdom – the Vedas – which might even contain the keys to the future of humanity ? Or the UN to point out that it is high time India adopted a uniform Civil Code, which does not discriminate between religions ? Or to clamour that Hindus have been the most oppressed minority in the world for the last ten centuries ? Wake up of Ô India, Thy time has come !

 

FRANCOIS GAUTIER

Advertisements

7 responses to “FOREIGNERS AND INDIA

  1. Indians no more trust their electronic or print media,hence it does not matter what it cries.They will cry foul on every step the new Govt takes.Its the Govt hat needs to be strong in its decisions.
    Even the wealthy country like US charges higher fee on foreign students.Hotel charges in India no doubt are higher compared to global market but other services are not.
    Good article 🙂

  2. Dear Francois, In stead of naming the controversial Teresa who disdained Hinduism , had positive Christian bias and proselitysing trend , you should have forgotten to name The Mother of Sri Aurobindo Ashram .
    I believe if you send the Blog to Modi something must be done about it . I had borrowed ‘Decolonizing Hindu Mind ‘ by Konrad , from you in Ashram .I wish to read your nes book on History !

  3. Avinash Kumar

    I wonder why Francois is not in a suitable position in PMO. I have vouched for him wherever I get an opportunity. Fellow readers pl compaign for a rightful place for him in the Govt . It will be a great service to the Nation.
    However thanks Francois for a very timely article. How I wish our tourism minister spares 20 minutes from his ” Busy Schedule ” to go through the eyeopner.
    Mr Francois Merci beaucoup for all that you are doing. God bless you.

  4. Ashok Sharma

    My children chide me for truth will prevail when they find it no where?pl give a road map for dharma

  5. Dear Sir,
    It is nothing short of a miracle that I discovered your blog so early in life – I’m just 21.. India needs you – wonderful people like you (I can hardly generalise as there are but few who came to India as an adult and loved her for who she is post Independence) in our media. Please write more and send them to The Indian Express. Your thoughts have to be heard.
    Your opinions are music to my ears after listening to the numerous news channels which are doing little to focus on what the issues of concern really are.
    On behalf of a billion Indians, I thank you for coming to India and for doing all that you have.

  6. Dear Francois,

    I am currently publishing an Expatriate only magazine which features small anecdotal/life and time account of foreign nationals in India. I wish to extend an invitation to you to write with us. Your critical views on travel and life in India are very welcome!

    I circulate this magazine all over India through selective channels (of ex-pats) and wish to create as many cross connections in the country with like-minded people as possible. The response in most foreign national communities has been huge, with most associations demanding more prints.

    Please let me know what you think and I am happy to send you a more formal invitation. I can email you a PDF copy(ies) for our October & November edition which we release end of this month. The hardcopy is for free – I don’t charge the readers anything and can mail a few to you to share among other ex-pat friends 🙂

    On a side note, I am looking out for expatriates who run or work with NGOs here or for that matter are running their own entrepreneurial setups so as to give them free promotion as well as create an encouraging platform for others to give India a try 🙂 If you know of any such enterprising souls, feel free to put them in touch with me – country no bar!

    Best Wishes,
    Shikha

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s